Welcome! Feel free to do a search and if you cannot find an answer, just ask!

what is the difference between taking a picture and making a video are both haram?

+1 vote
If you take a picture is this haram? what is th difference if you make a video?
asked Apr 9, 2012 by anonymous
   

1 Answer

+1 vote

no you see taking a picture is only haraam if it is of the creation, but taking pictures for instance the kabaa that is not hraam.

Shafie has made it Haraam to take pictures of People and Animals and everything that has a soul.  and He has made it alright to take images of a tree or rock or anything that does not have a soul.

and the Hikma of not taking pictures of something that has a soul is that the people of the prophets day used to make pictures and worship them, they did that with idols and live things too.  this is only one of a few hikmat on why not to take pictuires of something with a soul.

 

 

http://www.muhajabah.com/pictures-fiqh.htm

 

Fiqh of Picture-Making

 

As-salaamu alaykum,

There is somewhat of a difference of opinion among the scholars in regard to pictures and other types of images. Most scholars seem to agree that the display of images is at best makruh and should only be done in a limited way for specific reasons. Many scholars hold that some kinds of pictures are haram. The way that I understand it is the following:

1) Drawings of inanimate objects and plants are halal except if they are used for shirk. That is, if you draw a picture of a tree with the intention of worshiping the picture of the tree, then that is haram. But otherwise it is halal.

2) Drawings of animate objects such as animals and humans are in general considered to be haram with the following exceptions:
a) If the image is partial or incomplete and not a full-body image, then this is halal
b) If the facial features of the image have been erased even if it is a full-body image, then this is halal

3) There is a difference of opinion about whether photography is to be considered the same as drawings (this is the opinion of Shaykh Munajjid) or is in a class of its own that does not have the same restriction as drawings (this is the opinion of Shaykh Yusuf Qaradawi, among others).

It is my personal preference to avoid what is doubtful as much as I can and therefore to avoid the use of full-body photographs of humans and animals if I can use partial images, erase the facial features, or avoid the use of such images altogether. However, other people may feel differently.

It is certainly difficult to follow such a rule in modern society, but I do not feel that it is "extreme". Inshallah, if we refrain from doing something for the sake of Allah SWT, He will reward us, and especially so if the sacrifice is difficult for us.

W'as-salaam alaykum

By Al-Muhajabah

 

Now Videos are haraam only according to their conetnt if the video/s are useful and strengthin your deen and you learn from it than it is ok.  Videos of Kutbahs are alright even though it might be better to listen to a recording or listen live.

answered Apr 9, 2012 by Mujahid (236 points)
...